I was elated when the news broke about US Journalist, Jill Carroll, being released after being held hostage in Iraq, by an Islamic group calling themselves the Revenge Brigades for 82 days.
I am still elated she is alive and well, but I am now disturbed at the way her comments after her release were reported.
I have heard other reporters describe her comments about the ordeal as “praise” for her captors. I for one don’t feel that is the case.
Miss Carroll related that she was treated well, was not beaten, and was allowed to take showers and use the bathroom when she wanted.
Miss Carroll may be accurately describing conditions of her captivity and she may be thankful her ordeal was not more like that suffered by others, like Nick Berg, whose beheading was filmed to increase the shock and horror of the American public and for inciting more fanatical Islamic terrorism. But I think her comments fall far short of praise.
Think about it. You are free to use your bathroom at will. It is something so small, so ingrained and so normal that we usually don’t even consider it a freedom. Thankfully, the closest most of us will ever come to this, is traveling as a passenger in a car with a driver who has a stronger, larger bladder than we do. It was not praise. She is just thankful she was not forced to use a discarded tin can as a toilet, or was not kept bound and forced to suffer the indignity of soiling herself. Thankful that she was not beaten, or murdered on film for the viewing pleasure of those who hate anything and anyone even remotely connected with America.
At the time she was taken hostage, the driver of her vehicle was shot to death. She was taken captive, shown in tears on TV, and held for 82 days not knowing her eventual fate. I am sure any person in that situation would misperceive any humane treatment as an act of kindness.
It is nothing more than a version of the now famous Stockholm syndrome, where a hostage eventually becomes emotionally connected to their captor.
Reporters describing Carroll’s comments as “praise” are either so ignorant they should not be reporters, or they are twisting the facts to support their view of the situation. You be the judge.
The “Revenge Brigades” are murderers and kidnappers. They are so ineffectual, that they must resort to gunning down a vehicle’s driver and taking a reporter hostage…they deserve no praise and framing Jill Carroll’s comments as such is flat wrong.
Recent Comments